AISHE Logo
All Ireland Society for Higher Education

AISHE Inaugural Conference 2004

Thursday 2nd & Friday 3rd September 2004


[Conference Programme]

Evaluating the Effectiveness of Management Education: An Irish and International Study

Principle Proposer

Name: Buckley , Finian
Email: Finian.Buckley@dcu.ie
Institution: Dublin City University Business School

Additional Proposer(s) (if any)


Conway, Edel
Monks, Kathy
Kirrane, Melrona
MacKeogh, Kay
Barker, Pat

Abstract (Words: 299; Format: paper )



Recently some very searching questions have been asked of the
utility and functionality, not to mind the philosophical
integrity, of Management Education (Paauwe & Williams,
2001). As most adult or post experience management education is
sponsored by employers, there has been a demand for the
identification of financial and behavioural benefits to
organisations of management education (Burrow &
Berardinelli, 2003).

The current research seeks to establish the impact of management
education on individual and organisational outcomes in Ireland.
This report outlines the development of the Management Education
Effectiveness Questionnaire. The three-stage research plan
involves data collection as students begin their programme of
studies, again when they complete their education and again six
months after completion of the programme.

The study attempts to overcome the limitations associated with
previous evaluation research by including measures of important
pre-education antecedents such as Motivation to Learn,
Conscientiousness, and Self-efficacy. The researchers also hope
to gain independent verification of the impact of participation
in management education on workplace behaviour change by
including participant work colleagues in the research using a
separate evaluation questionnaire. The research, involving the
participation of four universities on the island of Ireland,
begun in November 2003. Universities in Australia, USA and
South Africa have also agreed to participate in the research
from 2004 forward.

The broad objectives and implications of the research are
presented. More tangibly initial data has been received and
collated and preliminary results regarding the relationship
between dispositional (personality) variables and workplace
behaviour are reported as well as expectations regarding
management education utility.


Burrow, J. & P. Berardinelli, 2003, "Systematic Performance
improvement - refining the space between learning and results" in
Journal of Workplace Learning, 15: 16-13.

Paauwe J. & R. Williams, 2001, "Seven key issues for
management development" in Journal of Management Development, 20:
2, 90-105.

(Abstract ref: #29.)



[Conference Programme]


All Ireland Society for Higher Education (AISHE)
Maintainer: info@aishe.org